Rekeying vs. Replacing Locks: Which Saves Your Sanity (and Wallet)?
Hey there, fellow security nerds! Let’s cut to the chase: you’re staring at your front door, keys in hand, wondering whether to rekey or replace those locks. Maybe you lost a key, moved into a new place, or just realized your current setup has the durability of a wet paper bag. Whatever the reason, we’ve all been there—stuck between saving cash and upgrading security. Lucky for you, we’ve got the lowdown (and a few laughs) to help you decide.
At LALA Locksmiths here in Los Angeles, we’ve rekeyed, replaced, and rescued more locks than we can count. Spoiler: There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. But stick with us, and we’ll break it down like a pro locksmith dismantles a stubborn deadbolt.
What Even Is Rekeying? (And Why It’s Not Magic)
Let’s start with the basics. Rekeying is like giving your lock a personality transplant without changing its body. A locksmith tweaks the lock’s internal pins so your old key stops working, and a new key takes over. It’s quick, budget-friendly, and perfect if you’re dealing with lost keys or questionable ex-roommates.
Why we love it:
- Cost-effective: Rekeying costs way less than buying brand-new hardware.
- Speed: Most jobs take 15–30 minutes. Perfect for impatient folks (we see you).
- Same Lock, New Key: Keep that vintage brass knob you love—just ditch the old keys.
But here’s the kicker: rekeying only works if your existing lock is in good shape. If it’s rusty, broken, or looks like it survived a zombie apocalypse, you’ll need to upgrade.
Pro Tip: If you’re Googling “locksmith near me” at 2 a.m. after a break-in, ask if they offer emergency locksmith services. Hint: We do.
When to Replace Locks: Because Sometimes You Gotta Go Nuclear
Replacing locks means swapping out the entire mechanism—knob, deadbolt, and all. It’s the nuclear option, but hey, sometimes you need that peace of mind.
You’ll want new locks if:
- Your lock is older than your Netflix password (looking at you, 1990s brass).
- You’ve got visible damage—think bent keys, rust, or that weird grinding noise.
- You’re upgrading security (smart locks, high-security deadbolts, etc.).
Downsides? It’s pricier and takes longer. But if you’re moving into a new Los Angeles pad and have zero clue who has copies of the keys? Replace those bad boys yesterday.
Fun Story: Last month, a client tried DIY lock replacement after a YouTube tutorial. Let’s just say… we also offer door lock repair services for a reason.
Cost Showdown: Rekeying vs. Replacement
Let’s talk numbers. Here’s a quick table to settle the “which is cheaper” debate:
| Factor | Rekeying | Replacing Locks |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | $20–$50 per lock | $50–$200+ per lock |
| Time | 15–30 minutes | 30–60 minutes |
| Security Upgrade | Minimal (same lock, new pins) | Major (new tech, better materials) |
| Ideal For | Lost keys, tenant changes, minor wear | Damage, upgrades, major wear |
FYI: If you’re a landlord, eviction locksmith services often include rekeying. It’s cheaper than replacing 10 locks on a studio apartment.
“But Can’t I Just DIY This?” (Spoiler: Please Don’t)
We get it—you’re handy! You’ve assembled IKEA furniture without crying! But locks? They’re sneaky little beasts. Missing one pin or over-tightening a screw can turn your front door into a decorative wall feature.
Leave it to a pro if:
- You’ve never taken apart a lock (no shame!).
- You need commercial locksmith services for your business.
- You’re dealing with a safe locksmith situation. Trust us, safes are a whole new level of finicky.
Plus, mobile locksmiths like us at LALA Locksmiths come to you. No hauling broken locks across Los Angeles in rush hour. Win-win.
Rekey or Replace? 3 Questions to Ask Yourself
-
“Is my lock physically intact?”
- Yes? Rekey.
- No? Replace.
-
“Am I upgrading security?”
- New smart lock = replacement.
- Just want new keys? Rekey.
-
“How’s my budget?”
- Tight? Rekey.
- Flexible? Replace.
Why Call a Pro? (Hint: We Fix Botched DIY Jobs)
Sure, you could buy a rekeying kit online. But let’s be real: most of us aren’t born door lock technicians. Here’s why pros rule:
- Guaranteed work: If something breaks, we fix it.
- No guesswork: We spot issues like worn pins or misalignment.
- Emergency help: Locked out? Our residential lockout service has your back.
Mild Brag: Last week, we rescued a client who’d jammed their auto door lock repair with a paperclip. Don’t be that person.
FAQs: Because We Know You’re Curious
Q: Can I rekey my locks myself?
A: Technically, yes. But unless you’ve got a locksmith toolkit and endless patience, call a door lock mechanic.
Q: How often should I rekey/replace?
A: Rekey when keys go MIA or tenants change. Replace every 5–7 years (or after damage).
Q: Is smart lock installation considered replacement?
A: Yep! And we love installing them.
Final Verdict: Keep Calm and Call LALA Locksmiths
So, rekey or replace? If your lock’s healthy and you just need new keys, rekeying’s your MVP. If it’s seen better days, treat yourself to an upgrade. Either way, skip the stress and let LALA Locksmiths handle it. We’re your friendly Los Angeles emergency locksmith, commercial lock repair wizards, and certified key nerds.
Still waffling? Hit us up. We’ll chat locks, life, or why LA traffic makes us all appreciate mobile locksmiths a little more. 😉
Need a pro today? Call LALA Locksmiths—because your door shouldn’t be a puzzle.
